Skip to main content
Sell Your Home
Shortlisted Properties
  • New Homes
  • For Sale
  • For Rent
Danger! Indicates a dangerous or potentially negative action.
Error

Maximum 4 project can be compared at one go.

Last Updated : 43 Days ago
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON, Port McNicoll
Photo Gallery
+ 39 Photos

58 Methodist Island, Tay MLS Number: S12910002

Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON, L0K 1R0

$899,900

Status: For Sale

  • 3+ Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • Area : 1100-1500 sqft
  • Property Type: Residential Freehold (Detached)
  • Property Taxes : $3669.47 (Tax Year:2025)
  • Listing Courtesy : Century 21 B.j. Roth Realty Ltd.

58 Methodist Island Property Description

A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by. The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Muskoka room for extra sleeping quarters or peaceful retreat. This cottage can sleep up to 10 people comfortably. The hot tub extends your days outdoors into the evenings with sounds of laughter and joy from the kids. Inside turn on Netflix and watch movies on the 75 big screen. High speed internet when working remotely is top notch. This is more than a cottage, its a lifestyle!

Read More

58 Methodist Island Property Facts

Property Type :Residential Freehold
MLS Number :S12910002
Listing Type :Sale
Possession Date :
know more link icon
Last Updated :25 Mar, 2026 (43 Days ago)
Source :Toronto Regional Real Estate Board
Area :Simcoe
Postal Code : L0K 1R0

58 Methodist Island Property Price & Tax Insights

Price : $899,900
Property Taxes :$3669.47
Tax Year :2025

58 Methodist Island, Tay Property Details

Bedrooms :3 +
No. of Rooms :8
Heating :Baseboard
Cross Street :Methodist Island
Bathrooms :2
Fuel :Electric
Approx Square Footage :1100-1500 sqft
Fireplace/Stove :No
Virtual Tour
Dimensions 8
Kitchen :5.2 m x 9.34 m
Bedroom :4.47 m x 4.06 m
Bedroom 3 :3.15 m x 4.32 m
Bathroom :3.15 m x 1.24 m
Living Room :5.2 m x 5.03 m
Bedroom 2 :3.15 m x 2.94 m
Sunroom :3.33 m x 2.77 m
Bathroom :2.1 m x 1.14 m

Exterior Information

Exterior Finish :Board & Batten
Parking Space :0
Basement :No

58 Methodist Island, Tay - Price History

2026-03

23 Mar, 2026

TREB #S12910002

Listed

$899900.0

property sold history blur background
View More

Sign in to view full price history of this property

  • 0
  • 400k
  • 800k
  • 1.2M
  • 1.6M
  • 2M+
  • 0
  • 6
  • 12
  • 18
  • 24
  • 30+
  • 0
  • 6
  • 12
  • 18
  • 24
  • 30+

58 Methodist Island - Location Map and Landmarks

Last Updated : 6 Hours ago
3407 BAYOU Road, Simcoe, ON
$649000.0
  • 3 +0 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 2000-2500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 6 Hours ago
236 Cox Mill Road, Simcoe, ON
$1749000.0
  • 3 +2 Bd
  • 5 Ba
  • 2000-2500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 7 Hours ago
32 BONAVENTURE Place, Simcoe, ON
$689777.0
  • 3 +0 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 1100-1500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 7 Hours ago
21 Silver Trail, Simcoe, ON
$929000.0
  • 2 +1 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 1100-1500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 7 Hours ago
2533 Flos 3 Road W, Simcoe, ON
$774900.0
  • 2 +1 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 1100-1500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 8 Hours ago
39 Vanderpost Crescent, Simcoe, ON
$1690000.0
  • 4 +2 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 2000-2500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 8 Hours ago
2606 Crossland Road, Simcoe, ON
$565000.0
  • 3 +1 Bd
  • 1 Ba
  • 1100-1500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 8 Hours ago
25 Copeland Creek Drive, Simcoe, ON
$1799777.0
  • 2 +3 Bd
  • 5 Ba
  • 3500-5000 sq-ft
Last Updated : 9 Hours ago
641 Bay Street, Simcoe, ON
$649777.0
  • 3 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 1100-1500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 9 Hours ago
1936 PENINSULA POINT Road, Simcoe, ON
$1088000.0
  • 4 +3 Bd
  • 4 Ba
  • 2000-2500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 9 Hours ago
1009 Langford Boulevard, Simcoe, ON
$1450000.0
  • 5 +2 Bd
  • 5 Ba
  • 3000-3500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 9 Hours ago
66 Albion Lane, Simcoe, ON
$899900.0
  • 4 +2 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 1500-2000 sq-ft
Last Updated : 9 Hours ago
11 Club Court, Simcoe, ON
$888000.0
  • 3 +1 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 1500-2000 sq-ft
Last Updated : 10 Hours ago
992 Green Street, Simcoe, ON
$888888.0
  • 4 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 2000-2500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 10 Hours ago
243 River Road E, Simcoe, ON
$749000.0
  • 4 +1 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 2000-2500 sq-ft
Last Updated : 1 Day ago
305 Ouida Street, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 1 Day ago
3282 Ogdens Beach Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 6 Days ago
1968 Rosemount Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 9 Days ago
257 Robins Point Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 10 Days ago
100 Alcove Drive, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 21 Days ago
150 AMANDA Street, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 23 Days ago
365 Robins Point Road, Simcoe, ON
$474900.0
  • 3 Bd
  • 1 Ba
  • 700-1100 sq-ft
Last Updated : 35 Days ago
185 Park Street, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 36 Days ago
121 Mitchells Beach Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 37 Days ago
5411 Elliott Side Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 56 Days ago
5263 Elliott Side Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 86 Days ago
PART 1 Ron Jones Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 86 Days ago
PART 2 Ron Jones Road, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 97 Days ago
379 ROPE Boulevard, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated : 163 Days ago
7183 Hwy 93 Highway, Simcoe, ON
Last Updated :686 Days ago
2 Swan Lane, Tay, ON
$999000.0
  • 3 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :411 Days ago
426 Seventh Avenue, Tay, ON
$124900.0
  • 0 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :340 Days ago
746 Sixth Avenue, Tay, ON
$499999.0
  • 3 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :370 Days ago
555 Barnes Avenue, Tay, ON
$139999.0
  • 0 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :315 Days ago
47 Dock Lane, Tay, ON
Price On Request
  • 6 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :356 Days ago
258 Patterson Boulevard, Tay, ON
Last Updated :1803 Days ago
7 Dock Lane, Tay, ON
$1899900.0
  • 3 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :416 Days ago
401 MCNICOLL Street, Tay, ON
$129900.0
  • 0 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :415 Days ago
53 Dock Lane, Tay, ON
$2199900.0
  • 3 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :415 Days ago
503 Margaret Street, Tay, ON
$129900.0
  • 0 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :1812 Days ago
9 Dock Lane, Tay, ON
$1699900.0
  • 4 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :510 Days ago
19 Dock Lane, Tay, ON
$599000.0
  • 1 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :510 Days ago
21 Dock Lane, Tay, ON
$599000.0
  • 1 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Last Updated :367 Days ago
3 Earldom Boulevard, Tay, ON
$674900.0
  • 2 Ba
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Recently Viewed

FAQs: 58 Methodist Island, Tay

  • Q:What is the Area Size of the 58 Methodist Island In Sq.Ft and it's MLS No.?

    A: The project covers an area of approximately 1100-1500 sq. ft and is strategically located in Simcoe. The MLS No of this project is S12910002 and the Project is located in ON, Canada
  • Q: Does this Project 58 Methodist Island available for Sale ?

    A: The project 58 Methodist Island is readily available for Sale and can be purchased at competitive prices today. You can schedule a tour or request a call back for knowing further.
  • Q: How far is this property from my workplace?

    A:You can calculate your travel time and see how this property is far from your Office, your spouse's workplace or your kid's school. You just need to tell us which places you commute to frequently and Square Yards will tell you how far they are from this property.
  • Q:What are the Key Features 58 Methodist Island is Offering?

    A:Square Yards is giving a Cashback of $4,500 if you buy this property from us, however there are several key features offered by the 58 Methodist Island. You get 3+ Beds with 2 Bath, central air conditioning, parking space and garage along with a heating system, basement, gas fuel system and balcony.
  • Q:How many Parking Space available in this 58 Methodist Island?

    A: 58 Methodist Island in Simcoe offers a total of 0 parking spaces for residents.
  • Q:How many Beds & Baths available in 58 Methodist Island, Simcoe?

    A: 58 Methodist Island, Simcoe comes with 3+ Beds for maximum convenience and space. There are 2 baths available as well for when you have guests over or if you have a large family!
  • Q:How many Apartments and Condos are available for Sale in Simcoe, On?

    A:Simcoe, ON is one of the biggest real estate markets in Canada. There are several options available here pertaining to condos and apartments alike. There are approximately apartments and condos available currently for your perusal.
Related to your search
Nearby Postal Codes of Simcoe

Tell us a Little about yourself!