Skip to main content
Sell Your Home
Shortlisted Properties
  • New Homes
  • For Sale
  • For Rent
Danger! Indicates a dangerous or potentially negative action.
Error

Maximum 4 project can be compared at one go.

Houses for Sale in Port McNicoll Tay

Explore Port McNicoll Neighbourhood
Showing results 1 - 12 of 12

Uncover the perfect place to call home in Port McNicoll, Tay with Square Yards Canada. Refine your search by filtering properties based on age, price trends, and other criteria to find your best pick. Choose from a wide range of properties across Port McNicoll, Tay real estate, offering various square footage options for all needs. Explore a detailed brochure of all houses for sale in Port McNicoll, and pick from a range of popular amenities like swimming pools, parking facilities, gyms and more. With over 12 properties on offer, find various residential and commercial properties across Port McNicoll, Tay. Navigate through MLS listings to know the top pick across Port McNicoll, Tay.


Property Types Available in for Sale

Find your perfect property match in Port McNicoll! From charming lands to expansive lands, we boast a wide variety of properties for Sale to suit every taste and budget. Whether you're a first-time buyer or a seasoned investor, Port McNicoll offers an exciting selection of properties priced between $459K and $87 Million. Start your real estate journey in Port McNicoll today!


Property Type Min Price Max Price Avg Listing Price Property Count
Land $459K $87 Million $19 Million 7

Bedroom Types Available in for Sale

Find your dream home in Port McNicoll with a vast selection of bedroom options for Sale. Tailored to all desires, the market offers cozy 1-bedroom units all the way to expansive 5+ bedroom residences. Explore a spectrum of living spaces, including 1-bedroom, 2-bedroom, 3-bedroom, and more. With prices ranging from a budget-friendly $799K to a luxurious $799K, discover the ideal match for your needs and financial aspirations.


Unit Type Min Price Max Price Avg Listing Price Property Count
3-bedroom $799K $799K $799K 1

Last Updated: March 23, 2026
  • New Listings
  • Price(Lo-Hi)
  • Price(Hi-Lo)
  • Bedrooms(Hi-Lo)
  • Bathrooms(Hi-Lo)
  • Square Feet(Lo-Hi)
  • Square Feet(Hi-Lo)
8 Photos
Last Updated : 6 Hours ago
401 MCNICOLL Street, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12453927 , Image - 1
Image With Blur overlay

Like What you see?

401 MCNICOLL Street Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12453927

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$129900.0
Lovely treed lot 76 x 118 ft to build your home or cottage on in Port McNicoll. Located close to Georgian Bay where you can fish, swim, boat in the su
39 Photos
Last Updated : 9 Hours ago
58 Methodist Island, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12910002 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

58 Methodist Island Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12910002

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$899900.0
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1100-1500 sq-ft
A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 island
40 Photos
Last Updated : 3 Days ago
2 Swan Lane, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12902836 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

2 Swan Lane Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12902836

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$999000.0
  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3000-3500 sq-ft
With its cupola, refined rooflines, and inviting front porch, the home makes a striking first impression.. Tucked at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac in
50 Photos
Last Updated : 6 Days ago
53 Dock Lane, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12676364 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

Unit-27, 53 Dock Lane Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12676364

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$2199900.0
price drop iconPrice drop by 4.3%
  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3000-3500 sq-ft
Welcome to Port McNicoll's best - kept secret, Exclusive community, serene peninsula on Georgian Bay, offering an unparallel waterfront living. This s
1 Photos
Last Updated : 20 Days ago
503 Margaret Street, Simcoe, ON
503 Margaret Street Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12838214

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$129900.0
  • < 700 sq-ft
Turn your vision into reality on this great residential building lot in Port McNicoll, a charming waterfront community on the shores of Georgian Bay.
32 Photos
Last Updated : 24 Days ago
9 Dock Lane, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12826154 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

9 Dock Lane Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12826154

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$1699900.0
  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Top 5 Reasons You Will Love This Home: 1) Indulge in the epitome of waterfront living, where expansive decks and private balconies offer the idyllic s
12 Photos
Last Updated : 38 Days ago
19 Dock Lane, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12741416 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

19 Dock Lane Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12741416

Residential Condo & Other (Vacant Land Condo)

$599000.0
  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 0-499 sq-ft
Welcome to #19 Dock Lane! Rare 70-ft waterfront lot on a protected bay with deep-water access to Georgian Bay, surrounded by high-end custom homes. In
12 Photos
Last Updated : 38 Days ago
21 Dock Lane, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12741420 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

21 Dock Lane Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12741420

Residential Condo & Other (Vacant Land Condo)

$599000.0
  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 0-499 sq-ft
Welcome to #19 Dock Lane! Rare 70-ft waterfront lot on a protected bay with deep-water access to Georgian Bay, surrounded by high-end custom homes. In
8 Photos
Last Updated : 39 Days ago
426 Seventh Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12784396 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

426 Seventh Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12784396

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$124900.0
  • < 700 sq-ft
READY TO QUIT THE RAT-RACE? Tay/Port McNicoll may just be the spot you've been looking for. The area offers a relaxed, small-town atmosphere for those
32 Photos
Last Updated : 40 Days ago
3 Earldom Boulevard, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12337867 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

3 Earldom Boulevard Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12337867

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$674900.0
price drop iconPrice drop by 3.6%
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1500-2000 sq-ft
Welcome to 3 Earldom Boulevard located in the quiet community of Port McNicoll, walking distance to the lake! This tastefully appointed 3-bedroom, 2-b
13 Photos
Last Updated : 44 Days ago
250 Kingfisher Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12654300 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

250 Kingfisher Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12654300

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$299900.0
price drop iconPrice drop by 14.1%
  • 700-1100 sq-ft
You've just arrived in Paradise Point! This Seasonal cottage sits on a 60' x 146' lot in the heart of this beloved community. Potential !!! Project to
39 Photos
Last Updated : 159 Days ago
18 Swan Lane, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12462707 , Image - 1

Like What you see?

18 Swan Lane Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12462707

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$1889000.0
  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 2500-3000 sq-ft
Welcome to picturesque Swan Lane, where luxury meets tranquility. It is located in a cul-de-sac, on a large premium & private waterfront lot. Wake up
Shortlisted Properties
error icon
Error

Maximum 4 project can be compared at one go.

Related to your search
Tell us a Little about yourself!