minPriceVal

maxPriceVal

minSize

maxSize

Houses for Sale in Port McNicoll Tay Under $500K

Showing results 1 - 19 of 19

Looking for houses under $500k for sale in Port McNicoll, Tay? With Square Yards Canada, discover a vast range of properties within your budget in Port McNicoll across Toronto. If you plan to buy houses under $500k in Port McNicoll, Tay, you can refine your search by property size, specific amenities, and property age. Filter the listings by the number of bedrooms, bathrooms, and surface area to match your requirements. Our listings feature a wide range of Port McNicoll houses for sale under $500k, including freehold properties, condos, and commercial spaces.

Last Updated: September 20, 2026

38 Photos

183 Paradise Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13127128 , Image - 1

183 Paradise Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13127128

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$379000.0

Price drop by 5.2%

3 Beds
1 Baths
< 700 sq-ft

Welcome to 183 Paradise Avenue, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home located in the heart of beautiful Port McNicoll. Just minutes from the waterfront, this pr

1 Photos

Unit-Lot 86, 548 Fifth Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13720338

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$79969.0

Vacant land property spans 56x112 feet, providing a spacious area for designing and building a dream home or cottage retreat. The lot is elevated, off

50 Photos

247 Poplar Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13764016 , Image - 1

247 Poplar Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13764016

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$499000.0

2 Beds
2 Baths
2000-2500 sq-ft

RARE FIND! Beautifully maintained home nestled in a quiet, sought-after neighbourhood in Paradise Point. Just a short walk to the beach, this spacious

Open House : Sun Sep 20, 11:00 AM to 01:00 PM

18 Photos

317 Wardell Street, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13619686 , Image - 1

317 Wardell Street Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13619686

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$457900.0

Price drop by 4.6%

3 +0 Beds
1 Baths
700-1100 sq-ft

This newly renovated move-in ready home is a gem and ready to make it your own. Set on a large lot with a double detached garage that has heat and hy

1 Photos

503 Margaret Street Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13753440

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$129900.0

< 700 sq-ft

Turn your vision into reality on this great residential building lot in Port McNicoll, a charming waterfront community on the shores of Georgian Bay.

1 Photos

247 Dignard Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13431954

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$54900.0

Price drop by 15.4%

Don't wait to invest! Invest and wait! This property currently has a TT designation. There is opportunity to get in the next lottery through Tay Towns

30 Photos

817 Eighth Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13717290 , Image - 1

817 Eighth Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13717290

Residential Freehold (Semi-Detached )

$369000.0

2 Beds
1 Baths
700-1100 sq-ft

AFFORDABLE, MOVE-IN READY HOME IN A FAMILY-FRIENDLY COMMUNITY! Welcome to 817 Eighth Street in Port McNicoll, offering an excellent opportunity for fi

13 Photos

250 Kingfisher Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13702308 , Image - 1

250 Kingfisher Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13702308

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$269950.0

700-1100 sq-ft

You've just arrived in Paradise Point! This Seasonal cottage sits on a 60' x 146' lot in the heart of this beloved community. Potential !!! Project to

45 Photos

575 Simcoe Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13701246 , Image - 1

575 Simcoe Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13701246

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$499900.0

3 +1 Beds
2 Baths
1100-1500 sq-ft

Check out this three bedroom bungalow backing onto greenspace in Port McNicoll. This home features gas heat w/ central air, a spacious living room din

29 Photos

10 & 11 Methodist Island N/A, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13611936 , Image - 1

10 & 11 Methodist Island N/A Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13611936

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$499900.0

4 Beds
1 Baths
700-1100 sq-ft

Welcome to the kind of cottage where family traditions begin and are passed down for generations. A place where mornings start with coffee on the deck

4 Photos

136 Limestone Road, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12261077 , Image - 1

136 Limestone Road Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12261077

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$169000.0

EXCLUSIVE BUILDING RIGHTS(NO BUILDING HOLD), Build Your Dream Home Steps from Georgian Bay! Discover an incredible opportunity in the sought-after com

8 Photos

426 Seventh Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12784396 , Image - 1

426 Seventh Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12784396

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$124900.0

< 700 sq-ft

READY TO QUIT THE RAT-RACE? Tay/Port McNicoll may just be the spot you've been looking for. The area offers a relaxed, small-town atmosphere for those

47 Photos

440 David Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13572922 , Image - 1

440 David Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13572922

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$119900.0

HERE'S WHY 440 DAVID AVENUE COULD BE YOUR NEXT MOVE: READY FOR YOUR VISION - Whether you're dreaming of your first home, your forever home, or a peac

8 Photos

401 McNicoll Street, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S13246468 , Image - 1

401 McNicoll Street Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S13246468

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$115000.0

Build Your Georgian Bay Dream. Discover the perfect setting for your future home or cottage on this beautifully treed 76' x 118' lot in the growing wa

7 Photos

11 Swan Lane, Lot 45 Lane, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12369046 , Image - 1

11 Swan Lane, Lot 45 Lane Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12369046

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$375000.0

Build your dream home in one of the areas most desirable settings! This premium lot offers: Expansive Water Views, Wake up to breathtaking sunrises a

13 Photos

856 Ney Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12334440 , Image - 1

856 Ney Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12334440

Residential Freehold (Detached)

$499998.0

Price drop by 9.0%

4 +2 Beds
3 Baths
1100-1500 sq-ft

Opportunity, Lifestyle, and Versatility all in one! Nestled in the charming waterfront community of Port McNicoll, this spacious raised bungalow offe

6 Photos

554 Barnes Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12925242 , Image - 1

554 Barnes Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12925242

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$99000.0

Build your dream home on this prime vacant lot in a quaint neighbourhood, just a short walk to the shores of Georgian Bay. Located at 554 Barnes Avenu

2 Photos

505 Helen Duncan Street, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12840426 , Image - 1

505 Helen Duncan Street Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12840426

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$69900.0

Plan for a vibrant future in this lovely, quiet neighbourhood that sits in the centre of it all...the Georgian Bay, Midland, the Trans Canada Trail, V

2 Photos

230 Dignard Avenue, Simcoe, ON , MLS #S12840252 , Image - 1

230 Dignard Avenue Port McNicoll, Tay, Simcoe, ON MLS® S12840252

Residential Freehold (Vacant Land)

$99900.0

Grandview Beach Paradise Point...the name says it all! This stunning beach community is surrounded by water; just a lovely five minute stroll takes yo

Shortlisted Properties

Error

Maximum 4 project can be compared at one go.

Houses for Sale in Port McNicoll Tay Under $500K

Houses By Budget in Simcoe Communities

Property Type By Budget in Simcoe

Bedroom By Budget in Simcoe

Popular City Homes

Popular Simcoe Neighbourhood Homes

Popular Simcoe City Homes